The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Retreve finished at -5.7 PuttView Handicap in our 2026 mallet test. That ties it for third overall.

For $199? That’s not where you expect to find it.

The more interesting part isn’t just where it finished; it’s how it got there.

How We Test

MyGolfSpy’s Most Wanted Testing is powered by:

• Titleist Pro V1 golf balls are a key component in testing. Every shot hit in Most Wanted utilizes these golf balls. They have long been the gold standard in golf ball quality, and it is the only ball we trust to complete our Most Wanted testing.
• Foresight GC Quad – Foresight is the gold standard in camera-based launch monitor technology because it produces data we can rely on with every shot hit. For this test, our GC Quads captured 13,680 shots.
• The Indoor Golf Shop’s SIGPRO Premium – All of our testing is done indoors at our HQ in Yorktown, Va. With each test, our screens take an absolute beating. Thus, we need high-quality, durable impact screens to handle the workload. SIGPRO Premium exceeds our expectations.
• UNRL Apparel – The official staff apparel partner of MyGolfSpy, we rely on UNRL to keep staff comfortable and focused at providing the world-class testing.

No weak distance

The Cleveland doesn’t rely on one standout category. It’s steady across the board.

From short range, it posted a -5.8 which keeps it right in line with the better performers in the test. From long distance, it was even stronger at -9.3, showing the kind of speed control you typically see near the top of the leaderboard.

The middle is where things usually fall apart. That didn’t happen here. At -1.8 from mid-range, it’s not leading the test but it avoids the drop-off we saw from a number of otherwise strong putters. That’s a big part of why the total score holds up.

Top 5 mallet putters (2026 test)

Misses stay manageable

Just as important as what happens on a good putt is what happens on a poor putt.

The Cleveland finished with a 44.3 percent make rate and an average miss of 16.9 inches. That’s in line with the top of the field.

In addition, to finish with a -9.3 from long range, it had an average miss at that length of only 18.7 inches. That’s four inches closer to the hole than some of the worst putters for long distances.

This isn’t a one-year result

Cleveland showed a very similar profile in 2025. The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 10.5 finished at -6.8 overall, with:

• -5.7 (short)
• -7.0 (medium)
• -8.9 (long)

That’s a slightly different shape than the 2026 result but the outcome is the same: strong performance across all three distances without a category pulling the score down. Most importantly for many golfers, their price is a bit easier to wrap your mind around.

Final thoughts

If you’re in the market for a putter that’s proven itself in a test with models more than three times its price point, the Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Retreve is one to consider.