Your Friends and Neighbors is a strong return to our screens, dealing straight away with the complicated fallout of the first season. This time, however, it comes with a little less focus on the thievery and much more focus on the already established characters themselves. 

When we join the second season, Coop (Jon Hamm) and the rest of the wider ensemble are still trying to process the events from season one. Coop is back on fairly good terms with ex-wife Mel (Amanda Peet) and the rest of his family. Sam (Olivia Munn) is isolated from the rest of Westchester after framing Coop for murder, and importantly, the rest of the ensemble still has no idea Coop is occasionally robbing his neighbours with the help of Elena (Aimee Carrero). Trouble soon arrives in the form of James Marsden‘s Owen Ashe, who drifts into the neighbourhood with the effortless charm of someone who always gets what he wants. He’s absolutely exceptional in the role, threading the needle between charismatic and deeply unsettling in a way that makes him a standout in every scene.

I was pleased to see that the robbery sequences remain a visual highlight of the show, even if they come considerably less often this time around. There’s a distinctive, almost Sherlock mind-palace design to how the show frames the things Coop steals – stylish, visually striking, and genuinely fun to watch. However, things feel different this season because the show is more interested in the web of relationships and class anxieties around Westchester than in the previous season’s heist focus. The change in focus ends up being the season’s smartest move as it allows them to develop the characters in the ensemble. Barney (Hoon Lee), who felt like a supporting player in season one, is given genuine stakes this year. Bringing him properly into the criminal plot not only opens up new story avenues but also shifts the show from feeling like the Coop show into something more genuinely communal. Mel’s storyline (perimenopause anxieties and a slow-burning rage at the world) runs parallel nicely, grounding the more heightened plot in something recognisably human.

One of the quieter achievements of the season ends up being how fully realised the world of Westchester feels. By keeping the focus almost entirely within this one affluent bubble, the show has built up a social ecosystem with its own logic, hierarchies and pressure points. It’s a standout approach that enables the focus of the show, Your Friends and Neighbors, to become more about the friends and neighbours, if you will.

SUPPORT US!!! WE ARE A SMALL, INDEPENDENT FILM WEBSITE WITH NO BIG BACKERS, SO IF YOU LOVE OUR SITE AND OUR WRITERS, PLEASE CONSIDER HELPING US TO KEEP FILM JOURNALISM ALIVE!

I don’t remember the first season having a particularly noticeable focus or theme outside of following the shenanigans of Coop and his messy life. However, this season seems to have more of a conscious theme around characters worrying about ageing, legacy, loneliness, what they’ve built and whether it was worth it. It gives the show a more melancholic undertone that distinguishes it from the more regular dark comedy nature of the previous season. The slower, more character-driven pace may not be for everyone, and there are definitely moments where it feels like the writers are stretching to give every supporting face a subplot, but it means season two shapes up to be a much richer, more confident piece of television than its first.

It would also be remiss not to flag that the show’s most distinctive elements, the stylish robbery sequences and the central dynamic between Coop and Elena, take a significant back seat this season. Elena, in particular, feels underserved, surfacing occasionally but rarely with the presence she had in season one. It’s a curious, creative choice and an occasionally frustrating one, because those elements gave the show a texture and energy that the expanded ensemble doesn’t try to replicate. Season two is in many ways a better constructed piece of television than its predecessor, but it is also a stranger one, simultaneously a step forward and a step sideways, leaving you genuinely uncertain about where the show’s identity will settle by the time season three rolls around. It’s a confident expansion of the world that is also, somehow, a slight step away from what made it worth expanding in the first place.

The second season of Your Friends and Neighbors is a show in genuine creative flux, and that is both its biggest strength and its most honest limitation. It is richer, more ambitious and more emotionally grounded than season one, but it is also less immediately fun, and the trade-off is one you’ll feel depending on what drew you to it originally. It’s worth noting, though, that there’s no question around the quality of the cast’s performances. Hamm remains effortlessly watchable, and Marsden’s arrival gives the show a new gear it didn’t know it needed. Uneven in places, occasionally frustrating, but never less than compelling. This is a show still very much worth your time.

★★★★

Streaming weekly on Apple TV from April 3rd / Jon Hamm, Amanda Peet, Olivia Munn, Hoon Lee, Mark Tallman, Lena Hall, Aimee Carrero, Eunice Bae, Isabel Gravitt, Donovan Colan / Apple Studios / 15

Post navigation